| Brian | Matt | ESPN Experts |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Troy Smith | 1. Troy Smith | 1. Troy Smith |
| 2. Mike Hart | 2. Darren McFadden | 2. Brady Quinn |
| 3. Darren McFadden | 3. Mike Hart | 3. Darren McFadden |
| 4. Brady Quinn | 4. Colt Brennan | 4. Mike Hart |
| 5. Steve Slaton | 5. Brady Quinn | 5. Colt Brennan |
Our Thoughts
Brian – No changes for me this week as only Darren McFadden and Steve Slaton were in action. McFadden had a solid game and was one of the reasons Arkansas was able to hang with Florida as long as they did, but he didn’t do enough to win and didn’t do enough too move up my list. In the Rutgers/West Virginia game Ray Rice made a strong case for himself to be the Big East running back on my list over Steve Slaton, but overall Slaton has had the better season of the two.
Matt – No changes this week for me either. I was pretty surprised to hear that Brady Quinn won the Maxwell Award. What did everyone see from him this year? All I saw was that he played two good teams, and in both of those games they got killed. No way he should win anything over Troy Smith. McFadden is the only reason Arkansas did anything this season, and I think if it were not for Troy Smith he would have had a legitimate shot to win. Oh well, there is always next year.
reply to #1
brady
December 9th, 2006 at 8:52 pm
how in the world is Brady Quinn in ya’lls top 5? I’ve got nothin’ personal against the guy, but he hardly had a Heisman-like season. Where is Rutgers Ray Rice on your lists?